# ChangeLog for media-sound/sox # Copyright 1999-2015 Gentoo Foundation; Distributed under the GPL v2 # $Header: /var/cvsroot/gentoo-x86/media-sound/sox/ChangeLog,v 1.169 2015/07/17 15:19:43 ago Exp $ 17 Jul 2015; Agostino Sarubbo sox-14.4.2.ebuild: Stable for x86, wrt bug #511778 17 Jul 2015; Agostino Sarubbo sox-14.4.2.ebuild: Stable for ia64, wrt bug #511778 04 Jul 2015; Mikle Kolyada sox-14.4.2.ebuild: amd64 stable wrt bug #511778 04 Jul 2015; Tobias Klausmann sox-14.4.2.ebuild: Stable on alpha, bug 511778 31 May 2015; Markus Meier sox-14.4.2.ebuild: arm stable, bug #511778 28 May 2015; Jack Morgan sox-14.4.2.ebuild: ppc stable wrt bug #511778 28 May 2015; Jack Morgan sox-14.4.2.ebuild: sparc stable wrt bug #511778 28 May 2015; Jack Morgan sox-14.4.2.ebuild: adding ~sparc for Bug 511778 27 May 2015; Jeroen Roovers sox-14.4.2.ebuild: Stable for HPPA (bug #511778). 24 May 2015; Jeroen Roovers sox-14.4.2.ebuild: Stable for PPC64 (bug #511778). 25 Apr 2015; Jeroen Roovers sox-14.4.2.ebuild: Marked ~ppc64 (bug #543524). *sox-14.4.2 (16 Mar 2015) 16 Mar 2015; Alexis Ballier +sox-14.4.2.ebuild, metadata.xml: version bump 03 Mar 2015; Yixun Lan sox-14.4.1.ebuild: add arm64 support, tested on A53 board 11 Oct 2014; Alexis Ballier sox-14.4.1.ebuild, +files/sox-14.4.1-ffmpeg24.patch: fix build with ffmpeg 2.4+, bug #520188 03 Feb 2014; Akinori Hattori sox-14.4.1.ebuild: ia64 stable wrt bug #494346 06 Aug 2013; Alexis Ballier sox-14.4.1.ebuild, +files/sox-14.4.1-ffmpeg2.patch: fix build with ffmpeg-2, bug #478080 10 Mar 2013; Alexis Ballier -sox-14.3.2-r1.ebuild, -files/sox-14.3.2-ffmpeg.patch, -files/sox-14.3.2-uclibc.patch, -sox-14.4.0.ebuild: remove old 09 Mar 2013; Agostino Sarubbo sox-14.4.1.ebuild: Stable for alpha, wrt bug #459452 08 Mar 2013; Agostino Sarubbo sox-14.4.1.ebuild: Stable for arm, wrt bug #459452 04 Mar 2013; Jeroen Roovers sox-14.4.1.ebuild: Stable for HPPA (bug #459452). 03 Mar 2013; Agostino Sarubbo sox-14.4.1.ebuild: Stable for sparc, wrt bug #459452 03 Mar 2013; Agostino Sarubbo sox-14.4.1.ebuild: Stable for ppc64, wrt bug #459452 03 Mar 2013; Agostino Sarubbo sox-14.4.1.ebuild: Stable for ppc, wrt bug #459452 03 Mar 2013; Agostino Sarubbo sox-14.4.1.ebuild: Stable for x86, wrt bug #459452 03 Mar 2013; Agostino Sarubbo sox-14.4.1.ebuild: Stable for amd64, wrt bug #459452 *sox-14.4.1 (23 Feb 2013) 23 Feb 2013; Alexis Ballier +sox-14.4.1.ebuild, +files/sox-14.4.1-uclibc.patch: version bump 25 Nov 2012; Luca Barbato sox-14.4.0.ebuild, +files/sox-14.4.0-libav-9.patch: Support libav-9 13 Jul 2012; Alexis Ballier sox-14.4.0.ebuild, +files/sox-14.4.0-avcodec54.patch: Fix build with ffmpeg-0.11 / git master, bug #407621 05 May 2012; Michał Górny sox-14.3.2-r1.ebuild, sox-14.4.0.ebuild: dev-util/pkgconfig -> virtual/pkgconfig *sox-14.4.0 (07 Mar 2012) 07 Mar 2012; Tim Harder +sox-14.4.0.ebuild, +files/sox-14.4.0-ffmpeg.patch, metadata.xml: Version bump. 08 Feb 2012; Fabian Groffen sox-14.3.2-r1.ebuild: Marked ~x64-macos 01 Jan 2012; Raúl Porcel sox-14.3.2-r1.ebuild: Add ~ia64 28 Nov 2011; Samuli Suominen sox-14.3.2-r1.ebuild: Force more recent media-sound/lame wrt #391931 by Dave Kemper 23 Oct 2011; Samuli Suominen -sox-14.3.0.ebuild, -sox-14.3.1.ebuild, -files/sox-14.3.1-libpng15.patch, -files/sox-14.3.1-nomad.patch, -sox-14.3.2.ebuild: old 23 Oct 2011; Raúl Porcel sox-14.3.2-r1.ebuild: alpha/sparc stable wrt #386005 16 Oct 2011; Kacper Kowalik sox-14.3.2-r1.ebuild: ppc stable wrt #386005 15 Oct 2011; Markus Meier sox-14.3.2-r1.ebuild: arm stable, bug #386005 11 Oct 2011; Samuli Suominen sox-14.3.2-r1.ebuild: ppc64 stable wrt #386005 11 Oct 2011; Jeroen Roovers sox-14.3.2-r1.ebuild: Stable for HPPA (bug #386005). 08 Oct 2011; Pawel Hajdan jr sox-14.3.2-r1.ebuild: x86 stable wrt bug #386005 07 Oct 2011; Samuli Suominen sox-14.3.2-r1.ebuild: amd64 stable wrt #386005 *sox-14.3.2-r1 (07 Oct 2011) 07 Oct 2011; Samuli Suominen +sox-14.3.2-r1.ebuild: USE="static-libs" and empty dependency_libs in libtool files wrt #386029. Respect environment CFLAGS with USE="debug" wrt #386027. Thanks to Agostino Sarubbo for reporting. 18 Aug 2011; Matt Turner sox-14.3.0.ebuild, sox-14.3.1.ebuild, sox-14.3.2.ebuild: Add openmp USE flag, bug 371549. 14 Jun 2011; Matt Turner sox-14.3.2.ebuild: Added ~mips, bug 260095 16 May 2011; Alexis Ballier sox-14.3.2.ebuild, +files/sox-14.3.2-ffmpeg.patch: fix build with ffmpeg git 03 Apr 2011; Tomáš Chvátal sox-14.3.0.ebuild, sox-14.3.1.ebuild, sox-14.3.2.ebuild: Move from media-video/ffmpeg to virtual/ffmpeg. Fixes bug #361269. 29 Mar 2011; Samuli Suominen sox-14.3.2.ebuild, +files/sox-14.3.2-uclibc.patch: Fix compability with uClibc wrt #336123 by Erasmo Zubillaga. *sox-14.3.2 (28 Feb 2011) 28 Feb 2011; Alexis Ballier +sox-14.3.2.ebuild: version bump 16 Feb 2011; Alexis Ballier sox-14.3.1.ebuild, +files/sox-14.3.1-libpng15.patch: fix build with libpng 1.5 29 Apr 2010; Samuli Suominen sox-14.3.0.ebuild: Fix commit that was made 29 Dec 2009 to stabilize sox-14.3.0 for sparc. 29 Apr 2010; Samuli Suominen sox-14.3.1.ebuild, +files/sox-14.3.1-nomad.patch: Fix building with USE="-mad" wrt #317595 by Sergiy Borodych. *sox-14.3.1 (23 Apr 2010) 23 Apr 2010; Alexis Ballier +sox-14.3.1.ebuild, metadata.xml: version bump 07 Jan 2010; Christian Faulhammer sox-14.3.0.ebuild: Transfer Prefix keywords 29 Dec 2009; Raúl Porcel sox-14.3.0.ebuild: sparc stable wrt #291718 11 Dec 2009; Brent Baude sox-14.3.0.ebuild: Marking sox-14.3.0 ppc64 for bug 291718 06 Dec 2009; Tobias Klausmann sox-14.3.0.ebuild: Stable on alpha, bug #291718 12 Nov 2009; Jeroen Roovers sox-14.3.0.ebuild: Stable for HPPA (bug #291718). 08 Nov 2009; nixnut sox-14.3.0.ebuild: ppc stable #291718 04 Nov 2009; Markus Meier sox-14.3.0.ebuild: amd64/x86 stable, bug #291718 20 Oct 2009; Samuli Suominen sox-14.2.0.ebuild, sox-14.2.0-r1.ebuild, sox-14.3.0.ebuild: Remove amrnb and amrwb support wrt #252140. 09 Jul 2009; Samuli Suominen sox-14.3.0.ebuild: Change FFmpeg dep to >= 0.5 wrt #275683. *sox-14.3.0 (22 Jun 2009) 22 Jun 2009; Alexis Ballier +sox-14.3.0.ebuild: version bump 22 Jun 2009; Alexis Ballier sox-14.2.0.ebuild, sox-14.2.0-r1.ebuild: add pkgconfig dep 22 Jun 2009; Alexis Ballier -sox-14.1.0.ebuild, -files/sox-14.1.0-lavc.patch, -files/sox-14.1.0-runsox.patch: remove old *sox-14.2.0-r1 (10 Mar 2009) 10 Mar 2009; Steve Dibb +files/sox-14.2.0-file-5.0.patch, +sox-14.2.0-r1.ebuild: Add patch to build with file-5.0, bug 259652 26 Dec 2008; Raúl Porcel sox-14.2.0.ebuild: sparc stable wrt #250671 17 Dec 2008; Markus Meier sox-14.2.0.ebuild: amd64/x86 stable, bug #250671 16 Dec 2008; Jeroen Roovers sox-14.2.0.ebuild: Stable for HPPA (bug #250671). 12 Dec 2008; Joseph Jezak sox-14.2.0.ebuild: Marked ppc/ppc64 stable for bug #250671. 12 Dec 2008; Tobias Klausmann sox-14.2.0.ebuild: Stable on alpha, bug #250671 26 Nov 2008; Brent Baude sox-14.1.0.ebuild: stable ppc64, bug 245326 22 Nov 2008; Peter Volkov +files/sox-14.2.0-distro.patch, sox-14.2.0.ebuild: Don't try to get distro name from /etc/issue, bug #246299 thank Albert W. Hopkins for report. 14 Nov 2008; Alexis Ballier +files/sox-14.1.0-runsox.patch, sox-14.1.0.ebuild: dont try to run sox when building it, it's been dropped in 14.2 and can cause weird problems, bug #246300 *sox-14.2.0 (10 Nov 2008) 10 Nov 2008; Alexis Ballier +sox-14.2.0.ebuild: version bump, bug #246163 09 Nov 2008; Tobias Klausmann sox-14.1.0.ebuild: Stable on alpha, bug #245326 08 Nov 2008; nixnut sox-14.1.0.ebuild: Stable on ppc wrt bug 245326 07 Nov 2008; Jeroen Roovers sox-14.1.0.ebuild: Stable for HPPA (bug #245326). 05 Nov 2008; Markus Meier sox-14.1.0.ebuild: amd64/x86 stable, bug #245326 03 Nov 2008; Ferris McCormick sox-14.1.0.ebuild: Sparc stable, Bug #245326. 01 Oct 2008; Alexis Ballier +files/sox-14.1.0-lavc.patch, sox-14.1.0.ebuild: add patch merged upstream fo fix build with latest ffmpeg *sox-14.1.0 (05 Aug 2008) 05 Aug 2008; Alexis Ballier +sox-14.1.0.ebuild: version bump 07 Jul 2008; +files/sox-14.0.1-cross.patch, sox-14.0.1.ebuild: - cross compile love 13 Apr 2008; Alexis Ballier +files/sox-14.0.1-ffmpegheaders.patch, sox-14.0.1.ebuild: Add a patch to let it build with latest ffmpeg headers layout, bug #215926 13 Apr 2008; Alexis Ballier -files/sox-12.17.9-destdir.patch, -files/sox-12.17.9-largefile.patch, -files/sox-12.18.2-destdir.patch, -files/sox-14.0.0-noexternalgsm.patch, -sox-12.17.9.ebuild, -sox-12.18.2.ebuild, -sox-14.0.0.ebuild, -sox-14.0.0-r1.ebuild: remove unused versions 22 Mar 2008; Jeroen Roovers sox-14.0.1.ebuild: Stable for HPPA (bug #214013). 22 Mar 2008; Joseph Jezak sox-14.0.1.ebuild: Marked ppc stable for bug #214013. 22 Mar 2008; Raúl Porcel sox-14.0.1.ebuild: sparc stable wrt #214013 21 Mar 2008; Markus Meier sox-14.0.1.ebuild: amd64/x86 stable, bug #214013 21 Mar 2008; Brent Baude sox-14.0.1.ebuild: Marking sox-14.0.1 ppc64 for bug 214013 21 Mar 2008; Tobias Klausmann sox-14.0.1.ebuild: Stable on alpha, bug #214013 24 Feb 2008; Alexis Ballier sox-14.0.1.ebuild: Enable amr nb and wb now that is works, thanks to Sebastian in bug #210043 *sox-14.0.1 (30 Jan 2008) 30 Jan 2008; Alexis Ballier +sox-14.0.1.ebuild: version bump 01 Jan 2008; Brent Baude sox-14.0.0-r1.ebuild: marking sox-14.0.0-r1 ~ppc64 for bug 192736 26 Dec 2007; Raúl Porcel sox-14.0.0-r1.ebuild: Re-add ~alpha wrt #192736, thanks to Tobias Klausmann for testing 17 Dec 2007; Jeroen Roovers sox-14.0.0-r1.ebuild: Marked ~hppa (bug #192736). *sox-14.0.0-r1 (16 Dec 2007) 16 Dec 2007; Alexis Ballier +sox-14.0.0-r1.ebuild: use external libgsm, bug #192736 28 Nov 2007; Raúl Porcel sox-14.0.0.ebuild: alpha/sparc stable wrt #200051 26 Nov 2007; Jeroen Roovers sox-14.0.0.ebuild: Stable for HPPA (bug #200051). 24 Nov 2007; nixnut sox-14.0.0.ebuild: Stable on ppc wrt bug 200051 23 Nov 2007; Markus Rothe sox-14.0.0.ebuild: Stable on ppc64; bug #200051 23 Nov 2007; Markus Meier sox-14.0.0.ebuild: x86 stable, bug #200051 23 Nov 2007; Samuli Suominen sox-14.0.0.ebuild: amd64 stable wrt #200051 18 Sep 2007; Alexis Ballier +files/sox-14.0.0-noexternalgsm.patch, sox-14.0.0.ebuild: disable support for external gsm lib for now until it installs correct libs (pic), bug #192736 *sox-14.0.0 (11 Sep 2007) 11 Sep 2007; Alexis Ballier +sox-14.0.0.ebuild: version bump, dropping mips keyword for ladspa useflag and deps 05 Aug 2007; Samuli Suominen sox-12.17.9.ebuild, sox-12.18.2.ebuild: QA: Stop using prepallman in ebuilds for bug 140697. 15 Mar 2007; Alexis Ballier +files/sox-13.0.0-oggautomagic.patch, sox-13.0.0.ebuild: Make ogg optional *sox-13.0.0 (15 Mar 2007) 15 Mar 2007; Alexis Ballier +files/sox-13.0.0-flac113.patch, +sox-13.0.0.ebuild: Version bump, bug #170990 27 Nov 2006; Timothy Redaelli sox-12.18.2.ebuild: Added ~x86-fbsd keyword. *sox-12.18.2 (02 Oct 2006) 02 Oct 2006; Stefan Schweizer -files/sox-12.17.6-destdir.patch, -files/sox-12.17.7-destdir.patch, -files/sox-12.17.7-largefile.patch, +files/sox-12.18.2-destdir.patch, -files/sox-install.patch, -files/sox-soundcard.patch, -files/sox-wav-segfault.patch, -files/sox-wave-overflow.patch, -sox-12.17.5-r1.ebuild, -sox-12.17.6.ebuild, -sox-12.17.6-r1.ebuild, -sox-12.17.7-r1.ebuild, -sox-12.17.7-r2.ebuild, +sox-12.18.2.ebuild: version bump thanks to Jonathan Geisler in bug 137502, remove old 03 Sep 2006; Jeroen Roovers sox-12.17.9.ebuild: Install play man page (bug #144267). 29 Jul 2006; Jeroen Roovers sox-12.17.9.ebuild: After 1.5 years of testing, stable on HPPA. 16 Jun 2006; Diego Pettenò sox-12.17.5-r1.ebuild, sox-12.17.6.ebuild, sox-12.17.6-r1.ebuild, sox-12.17.7-r1.ebuild, sox-12.17.7-r2.ebuild, sox-12.17.9.ebuild: Remove gnuconfig update. 09 Apr 2006; Markus Rothe sox-12.17.9.ebuild: Stable on ppc64 06 Apr 2006; Joshua Jackson sox-12.17.9.ebuild: Stable on x86; bug #125908 05 Apr 2006; Joseph Jezak sox-12.17.9.ebuild: Marked ppc stable for bug #125908. 03 Apr 2006; Thomas Cort sox-12.17.9.ebuild: Stable on Alpha wrt Bug #125908. 03 Apr 2006; Jeremy Huddleston sox-12.17.9.ebuild: Stable sparc. 03 Apr 2006; Patrick McLean sox-12.17.9.ebuild: Stable on amd64 (bug #125908) *sox-12.17.9 (22 Jan 2006) 22 Jan 2006; +files/sox-12.17.9-destdir.patch, +files/sox-12.17.9-largefile.patch, +sox-12.17.9.ebuild: Version bump, resolves bug #119624. 27 Aug 2005; Markus Rothe sox-12.17.7-r1.ebuild: Stable on ppc64 *sox-12.17.7-r2 (25 Aug 2005) 25 Aug 2005; Diego Pettenò +files/sox-12.17.7-largefile.patch, +sox-12.17.7-r2.ebuild: Added largefile support as per bug #103578. 13 Jul 2005; Markus Rothe sox-12.17.7-r1.ebuild: added ~ppc64 12 Jun 2005; Bryan Østergaard sox-12.17.7-r1.ebuild: Stable on alpha. 12 Jun 2005; Joseph Jezak sox-12.17.7-r1.ebuild: Marked ppc stable. 30 May 2005; Gustavo Zacarias sox-12.17.7-r1.ebuild: Stable on sparc 28 May 2005; Jan Brinkmann -sox-12.17.3-r3.ebuild, -sox-12.17.4-r2.ebuild, sox-12.17.5-r1.ebuild, sox-12.17.6.ebuild, sox-12.17.6-r1.ebuild, -sox-12.17.7.ebuild, sox-12.17.7-r1.ebuild: Dont make use of the deprecated oggvorbis useflag any longer, see #94254. Marked 12.17.7-r1 stable on amd64 and x86. *sox-12.17.7-r1 (10 Mar 2005) 10 Mar 2005; Jan Brinkmann +sox-12.17.7-r1.ebuild: applied cleanuppatch which was suggested by Diego Petten *sox-12.17.7 (20 Feb 2005) 20 Feb 2005; Guy Martin sox-12.17.7.ebuild: Added ~hppa to KEYWORDS. 18 Feb 2005; Jan Brinkmann : version bump, fixes #81968 31 Dec 2004; Jeremy Huddleston sox-12.17.6-r1.ebuild: Still force oss on as alsa isn't 100% working. *sox-12.17.6-r1 (31 Dec 2004) 31 Dec 2004; Jeremy Huddleston +files/sox-12.17.6-destdir.patch, +sox-12.17.6-r1.ebuild: Destdir patch added. Alsa support added. Closes bug #75778. 29 Dec 2004; Ciaran McCreesh : Change encoding to UTF-8 for GLEP 31 compliance 10 Dec 2004; Joseph Jezak : Tested and marked ppc stable. *sox-12.17.6 (20 Nov 2004) 20 Nov 2004; Tony Vroon +sox-12.17.6.ebuild: Version bump. Upstream changelog mentions .wav segfault bug fixes, PPC users please test this. 12 Nov 2004; Bryan Østergaard sox-12.17.5-r1.ebuild: Stable on alpha. 18 Oct 2004; Jeremy Huddleston sox-12.17.5-r1.ebuild: Stable amd64, sparc, x86. 18 Oct 2004; Joseph Jezak +files/sox-wav-segfault.patch, sox-12.17.4-r2.ebuild, sox-12.17.5-r1.ebuild: Added -fsigned-char to sox-12.17.4-r2 and sox-12.17.5-r1 to fix bug #35745. Patch for wav segfaults in sox-12.17.5-r1, also bug #35745 14 Sep 2004; Jeremy Huddleston : Removing sox-12.17.5 as it installs exactly the same thing as -r1. -r1 should NOT have been added to portage. If you already have sox-12.17.5 installed, you will gain nothing by emerging sox-12.17.5-r1. *sox-12.17.5-r1 (11 Sep 2004) 11 Sep 2004; Doug Goldstein +sox-12.17.5-r1.ebuild: Disable ALSA support because it's broken in sox. See bug #63531. 11 Sep 2004; Jeremy Huddleston sox-12.17.5.ebuild: ALSA support is broken... using OSS by default. *sox-12.17.5 (09 Sep 2004) 09 Sep 2004; Jeremy Huddleston +files/sox-install.patch, +files/sox-soundcard.patch, +sox-12.17.5.ebuild: Version bump closes bug #62854. 11 Aug 2004; Brian Harring sox-12.17.4-r2.ebuild: Use flag operators -must- be wrapped in parenthesis, blah? node isn't valid. 30 Jul 2004; Bryan Østergaard sox-12.17.4-r2.ebuild: Stable on alpha. 29 Jul 2004; Jeremy Huddleston -sox-12.17.4-r1.ebuild: Removing insecure version. *sox-12.17.4-r2 (29 Jul 2004) 29 Jul 2004; Chris White +files/sox-wave-overflow.patch, +sox-12.17.4-r2.ebuild: Bumped to -r2 and added buffer overflow patch to address bug #57962. 07 Jul 2004; Hardave Riar sox-12.17.4-r1.ebuild: Added ~mips KEYWORD and gnuconfig_update 01 Jul 2004; Jeremy Huddleston sox-12.17.3-r3.ebuild, sox-12.17.4-r1.ebuild: virtual/glibc -> virtual/libc 19 Jun 2004; Jeremy Huddleston sox-12.17.4-r1.ebuild: Added alsa-lib to DEPEND when USE=alsa. 03 May 2004; Jeremy Huddleston sox-12.17.4-r1.ebuild: Changing mad dep to madplay. 20 Apr 2004; Jeremy Huddleston sox-12.17.3-r3.ebuild: Added IUSE. 11 Apr 2004; Jason Wever sox-12.17.4-r1.ebuild: Stable on sparc. 01 Apr 2004; Jason Wever sox-12.17.4-r1.ebuild: Added ~sparc keyword. 31 Mar 2004; Jeremy Huddleston sox-12.17.3-r1.ebuild, sox-12.17.4-r1.ebuild, sox-12.17.4.ebuild: Stable on x86. Removing old ebuilds. *sox-12.17.4-r1 (28 Nov 2003) 28 Nov 2003; Brad House sox-12.17.4-r1.ebuild: mark stable on amd64 26 Sep 2003; jje : Addition of USE flags, oggvorbis, mad, encode, oss, alsa. Submitted by: Roman Valls 12 Aug 2003; Jason Wever sox-12.17.3-r3.ebuild: Changed ~sparc keyword to sparc. 04 Aug 2003; Patrick Kursawe sox-12.17.3-r3.ebuild, sox-12.17.4.ebuild: Changed download URI to mirror://.... scheme as reported in bug 25652 *sox-12.17.4 (31 Jul 2003) 31 Jul 2003; rob holland sox-12.17.4.ebuild: Version bump. Fixes alsa issues from 12.17.3. Submitted by Andy Pyles . Closes #19021 *sox-12.17.3-r3 (21 Dec 2002) 21 Dec 2002; Arcady Genkin : The previous versions were not installing soxmix and play.1. Closes #12286. *sox-12.17.3-r2 (16 Oct 2002) 16 Oct 2002; Aron Griffis sox-12.17.3-r2.ebuild : Fixed to build even when Alsa libraries are present on the system. *sox-12.17.3-r1 (12 Jul 2002) 14 Aug 2002; Pieter Van den Abeele : Added ppc keyword 12 Jul 2002; phoen][x sox-12.7.3.ebuild : Added a symlink from /usr/bin/rec to /usr/bin/play (Bug 4925) Added KEYWORDS, LICENSE, SLOT. *sox-12.17.3 (1 Feb 2002) 11 May 2002; Arcady Genkin sox-12.7.3.ebuild : Updated to version 12.17.3.